Javascript is not enabled.

Javascript must be enabled to use this site. Please enable Javascript in your browser and try again.

Skip to content
Content starts here
CLOSE ×
Search
CLOSE ×
Search
Leaving AARP.org Website

You are now leaving AARP.org and going to a website that is not operated by AARP. A different privacy policy and terms of service will apply.

8 Dishes Not Worth Your Money at Restaurants

If you're on a budget, you want eating out to count. Professional chefs say to skip these menu items to get the most bang for your buck


Selective-focus image of Seared Scallops on a bed of vegetables
Getty Images

If you're on a fixed income, you've probably noticed your favorite dishes are more expensive or your eating out budget doesn't stretch as far as it used to. And you're right. The Consumer Price Index in December 2024 says prices at restaurants, casual dining and fast-food establishments are up 1.7 percent over the past 12 months. 

So when you do decide to eat out, you want to make it count. One way to do that: Know which dishes are actually worth the money you're spending — meaning the ingredients make sense for the cost of the dish and they aren’t easy to make at home. We spoke to four professional chefs about popular dishes they don't think are worth your money when you’re out to eat.

Shrimp cocktail

This menu staple is an appetizer that requires two ingredients — shrimp and cocktail sauce — and usually has a high price point at restaurants. It also incredibly simple to prepare at home.

"This is one of the easiest dishes in the world to make," says Richard LaMarita, chef-instructor of plant-based culinary arts at the Institute of Culinary Education’s New York City campus, adding that you can buy shrimp that is already deveined and peeled so all you have to do is cook it and plate it.

How much do older adults spend eating out?

On average people aged between 55-64 years old spend around $3,811 eating out a year and those aged 65 and older spend around $2,509, according to a report by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Even for the novice cook, cooking shrimp is easy. "You just simmer it in water for five minutes until the shrimp is done," says LaMarita."You don't want to overcook it."  Place shrimp so it hangs off the side of a bowl and pour cocktail sauce in the middle to dip. He adds restaurants buy pre-made cocktail sauce so if you make it at home and use store-bought sauce, it's the same as what you would get at a restaurant.

Scallops

Scallops may be a dish you seek out when you want to celebrate a special moment, but Bill Collins, a personal chef, who worked as a cook at the Ritz Carlton Boston, says it's a dish that's often over cooked at restaurants.

It's also rare to find quality scallops — meaning restaurants are often using scallops that are just so-so — he says. Good scallops are so hard to find, it’s a dish that Collins doesn’t even make himself very often. "I can't remember the last time I cooked them at home because I haven't loved the look of them in the market for that special meal." 

And scallops are pricey, often about $25 a pound, says Collins, who has also authored four cookbooks. When he does find quality ones, he likes to sear them at home. His tip to sear them to perfection: An instant thermometer that reads 135 degrees so the scallops are moist and cooked but not dried out.

Cheese platter

It's fun to share a cheese platter at a restaurant, but but they are very often overpriced for what you get, says LaMarita. He prefers to make a cheese platter at home because they are simple to prepare and more cost-effective.

"Slice up a few apples, slice up a little bread, throw some nuts or dried fruits on it," he says. You can choose the cheeses you like, you'll get more for your money, adding that you'll have cheese for three to four sittings for a similar price.

Quesadilla

Quesadillas are common breakfast food in Mexico, but in the States they are often served as an entree for lunch or dinner. The ingredients are simple — a tortilla with melted cheese. Raul Luis, chef and owner of Birrieria Chalio in California and Texas compares them to grilled cheese.

Save yourself some money and make them at home, says Luis, because they're easy to make and economical. Plus, many restaurants use more commercial style cheeses rather than specialty cheese, such as queso fresco, he says, adding that you can buy cheese for $3-12 a pound and a pack of 8- 12 count tortillas can cost $2-6. While the cost of a quesadilla at a restaurant can range from $10-16. The only caveat is most Mexican restaurants make their own tortillas, which add a lot of texture to the quesadilla, he adds.

Steak

A steak dinner has a nice ring to it and it's a popular go-to for a nice dinner out. But not for chefs, who often avoid ordering a steak because it's frequently not cooked to their liking and can be expensive. Collins prefers preparing steak at home where he can guarantee it will be cooked medium-rare.

When you order at restaurants, he says how it's cooked depends on the expertise of the line cook or chef that is preparing your steak. If it’s not cooked how you like it, you’ve just spent a lot of money on a simple meal that you could make at home.

"If you go to a steakhouse, a lot of times, they're charbroiling it, they're grilling it, they're pan seering it," says Marcus Mooney, executive chef of Seattle Sutton's Healthy Eating. Those are easy techniques you can do at home. He adds that restaurants typically have a 60-70 percent markup on the steak price. That means, for the same price or less you'd spend at a restaurant, you can buy a quality cut and make it at home.

Entree salads

Mooney is always shocked at the salad prices when he looks at a menu, which can run $15 to $20 and up.

"A lot of these places, all they are doing is taking some lettuce and already prepared items and throwing them in the bowl and mixing them up with the dressing," he says. And most dressings aren't housemade, either.

Mooney prefers to make salads at home with either a store-bought dressing or make his own. LaMarita agrees and says salads are cheap to make and says many restaurants don't put much thought into how they prepare their salads.

Salmon

Ordering salmon may be a special dish if you don't typically eat fish at home, but Collins says like scallops, salmon is often overcooked at restaurants. Plus it’s easy to make at home, says Mooney.

If you want to always cook your fish properly, Collins offers a tip: "The rule of thumb for cooking any kind of fish is 10 minutes for every inch of thickness of the fish, [whether] you poach it, you pan sear, roast it."

He shares one of his favorite ways to prepare salmon at home. "Salmon, oil, salt and pepper, roasted in the oven at 450 [degrees Fahrenheit] for about 12-14 minutes, depending on how thick the fish is with a little parchment paper on top," he says.

Cakes and pies

Most chefs say they wouldn't order pies or cakes at a restaurant, unless they know they're made in-house. Chefs recommend going to a bakery for quality instead since they take time and skill to make it from scratch.

"I would go to a dedicated bakery or a farmers market [where they] are freshly made," says LaMarita, adding that it's likely less expensive or around the same price at a bakery compared to a restaurant.

An added tip: Skip cakes and pies in the supermarket too, he says.

Unlock Access to AARP Members Edition

Join AARP to Continue

Already a Member?